By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in West Islip,NY.

# Italianos Pizzeria & Restaurant

5 Udall Rd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-587-1172

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Brownstones Coffee

306 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-661-6113

Dishes Served:

Diner

# Captree Gourmet Deli

462 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-669-9663

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Hersheys Ice Cream

470 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-422-5200

Dishes Served:

Desserts, Ice Cream

# Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

636 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-661-6246

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Higbie Bagels

264 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-587-1995

Dishes Served:

# Lion's Den

191 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-482-9922

Dishes Served:

# Hogan's Delicatessen

17 Udall Rd
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-661-9115

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# West Islip Bagel

544 Hunter Ave
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-321-1769

Dishes Served:

# Best Kitchen

787 Udall Rd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-422-6919

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Bagels Buzz

498 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-587-7449

Dishes Served:

# Cafe Europa

504 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-587-7000

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Uncle Chucks

401 Sunrise Hwy
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-893-4360

Dishes Served:

American

# Atlantis Diner

350 Montauk Hwy
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-587-2003

Dishes Served:

Diner

# Panda Garden Chinese Restaurant

270 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-661-1122

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Farrell's of Brooklyn

263 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-482-1951

Dishes Served:

Bar Food

# Hometown Heroes

240 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-321-4000

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Crispino's Pizza

159 Higbie Ln
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-893-8000

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Hai-Shang

510 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-661-2707

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Villa Monaco Restaurant

778 Montauk Hwy
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-661-5599

Dishes Served:

Italian

# Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering

945 Montauk Hwy
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-669-4400

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Oak Neck Deli

945 Montauk Hwy
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-661-9701

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Long River Chinese Restaurant & Takeout

351 Union Blvd
West Islip , NY 11795

Visit Website
Ph: 631-669-4982

Dishes Served:

Asian, Chinese, Sushi

# Ken's Delicatessen & Caterers

793 Udall Rd
West Islip , NY 11795

Ph: 631-661-7156

Dishes Served:

Sandwich