By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in Shirley,NY.

# Mr Domenic's Pizza

800 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-399-2700

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Freshy Fresh Bagels

917 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-281-2243

Dishes Served:

# Tend Coffee

924 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-772-4707

Dishes Served:

Coffee and Tea, Tea

# Shirley Xpress Delicatessen

600 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-281-5054

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Colin Deli

132 Colin Dr
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-205-2520

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Okeno Sushi

451 Glen Dr
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-8188

Dishes Served:

Asian, Japanese, Sushi

# Carlo's Pizza Shirley

451 Glen Dr
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-924-8760

Dishes Served:

Italian, Pizza

# Sweet Garden Chinese Restaurant

234 County Rd 46
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-399-4828

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Tony's Sushi Pan-Asian Restaurant

77 Northern Blvd
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-281-0009

Dishes Served:

Asian, Chinese, Japanese

# Chun Bo Chinese Food💯💯

60 Northern Blvd
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-399-5292

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream

990 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-863-0199

Dishes Served:

# Joe's Pizza

433 William Floyd Pkwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-281-7277

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Savarona's Pizzeria

999 Montauk Hwy #22
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-395-0555

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Hero Haven & More Inc

478 Neighborhood Rd A
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-399-3802

Dishes Served:

Deli

# Oriental Kitchens

451 Glen Dr # F
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-924-1333

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# Vincent's Pizza

44 Surrey Cir
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-395-5695

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Romano's Pizza

55 Surrey Cir
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-399-0888

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Mastic Deli & Market

234 William Floyd Pkwy #2
Shirley , NY 11967

Ph: 631-281-7210

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# May Garden

999 Montauk Hwy
Shirley , NY 11967

Visit Website
Ph: 631-281-0033

Dishes Served:

Chinese