By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in Shelter Island,NY.

# Salt

63 Menantic Rd
Shelter Island , NY 11964

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-3355

Dishes Served:

Bar Food, Cafe

# 18 Bay

23 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island , NY 11964

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-0053

Dishes Served:

International, Italian

# Ram's Head Inn

108 S Ram Island Dr
Shelter Island Heights , NY 11965

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-0811

Dishes Served:

American

# Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Rd
Shelter Island Heights , NY 11965

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-5659

Dishes Served:

American

# The Flying Goat Resturant

26 Sunnyside Dr
Shelter Island Heights , NY 11965

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-5656

Dishes Served:

American

# The Chequit

23 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights , NY 11965

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-0018

Dishes Served:

American

# Stars Cafe

17 Grand Ave
Shelter Island , NY 11964

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-3484

Dishes Served:

Cafe

# Tuck Shop

75 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island , NY 11964

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-1548

Dishes Served:

Desserts

# Vine Street Café

41 S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island , NY 11964

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-3210

Dishes Served:

American

# The Dory

185 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island Heights , NY 11965

Visit Website
Ph: 631-749-4300

Dishes Served:

Burger, Seafood, Steak