By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in New Windsor,NY.

# ABC

198 Quassaick Ave
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-562-2060

Dishes Served:

Italian, Pizza

# Hoagie Barmichaels

1101 River Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Ph: 845-561-8600

Dishes Served:

Bar Food

# Primo's

573 Union Ave
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-569-4463

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Frank's Pizza and Restaurant

179 Temple Hill Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-565-4600

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Ikaros Diner

909 Union Ave
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-567-2600

Dishes Served:

American, Greek

# Cinema Pizza

215 Quassaick Ave #105
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-391-3070

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Preet Gourmet Pizza & Deli

1035 Little Britain Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-567-3409

Dishes Served:

Pizza, Sandwich

# Baker's Dozen

179 Temple Hill Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-565-5131

Dishes Served:

# Sweet Pea's

318 Blooming Grove Turnpike
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-391-8034

Dishes Served:

American

# Clearwater's Pizzeria

318 Blooming Grove Turnpike
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-565-3650

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Duck Town Inn

246 Walsh Ave
New Windsor , NY 12553

Ph: 845-562-9877

Dishes Served:

Burger, Italian, Pizza

# Chapala Grill

335 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-391-3133

Dishes Served:

Mexican

# Pizza Heaven

357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-569-8888

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Anthony's Deli

287 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-569-8707

Dishes Served:

Deli

# Villa Roma Pizzeria

266 Quassaick Ave
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-565-7778

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Matsons Delicatessen & Catering

538 Temple Hill Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-568-3354

Dishes Served:

Deli

# Not Just Salads

215 Quassaick Ave # 101
New Windsor , NY 12553

Ph: 845-561-5550

Dishes Served:

Healthy Food

# Irish Eyes Pub

2956 Us Route 9W
New Windsor , NY 12553

Ph: 845-562-9867

Dishes Served:

Bar Food

# Hot Bagel

500 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor , NY 12553

Ph: 845-568-0161

Dishes Served:

# Cafe Richiesto

1795 NY-32 #100
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-458-5513

Dishes Served:

Italian

# Marcelino's

1020 NY-94
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-569-9100

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Chopstick

377 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-561-0088

Dishes Served:

Asian, Sushi

# LA CASA VICINA

1015 Little Britain Rd
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-567-1890

Dishes Served:

Italian

# Citrus

1004 New York 94
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-787-4947

Dishes Served:

Indian, Thai

# Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria

359 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor , NY 12553

Visit Website
Ph: 845-562-2170

Dishes Served:

Italian, Pizza