By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in Montauk,NY.

# Muse @ The End

41 S Euclid Ave
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-238-5937

Dishes Served:

Italian

# South Edison

17 S Edison St
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-4200

Dishes Served:

Seafood

# Montauk Bake Shoppe

29 The Plaza A
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2439

Dishes Served:

# Coast Kitchen at The Montauk Yacht Club

32 Star Island Rd
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-3100

Dishes Served:

American

# Gosman's Clam Bar

484 W Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2549

Dishes Served:

Seafood

# Naturally Good

779 Montauk Hwy
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-6852

Dishes Served:

American, Coffee and Tea, Cafe

# Left Hand Coffee

83 S Elmwood Ave
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-238-5434

Dishes Served:

Coffee and Tea, Desserts

# Ruschmeyer's

161 2nd House Rd
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2877

Dishes Served:

American

# Primavera Pizza

54 S Erie Ave B
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-8888

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Tauk at Trail's End

63 S Euclid Ave
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2133

Dishes Served:

American

# 668 The Gig Shack

782 Main St
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2727

Dishes Served:

International, Seafood, Bar Food

# Continental Market

34 S Etna Ave # A
Montauk , NY 11954

Ph: 631-668-6060

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Bliss Kitchen

732 Montauk Hwy
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-8206

Dishes Served:

American, Breakfast, Sandwich

# BuddhaBerry Frozen Yogurt Cafe

43 S Euclid Ave
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-8393

Dishes Served:

# Swallow East

474 W Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-8344

Dishes Served:

American, Seafood

# East By Northeast

51 Edgemere St
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2872

Dishes Served:

Asian

# Herb's Market

778 Montauk Hwy
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-2335

Dishes Served:

Deli

# Joni's

28 S Etna Ave #9
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-3663

Dishes Served:

Breakfast

# Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities

781 Montauk Point State Pkwy # B
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-329-1100

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Bird On the Roof

47 S Elmwood Ave
Montauk , NY 11954

Ph: 631-668-5833

Dishes Served:

American

# Dave's Gone Fishing

467 E Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-6600

Dishes Served:

Breakfast, Seafood

# Inlet Seafood Restaurant

541 E Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-4272

Dishes Served:

American, Seafood

# Sammys

448 W Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-238-5707

Dishes Served:

Seafood

# O’Murphy’s

432 W Lake Dr
Montauk , NY 11954

Visit Website
Ph: 631-668-5005

Dishes Served:

Bar Food

# Meli G Deli

S Embassy St
Montauk , NY 11954

Ph: 631-668-2323

Dishes Served:

Sandwich