By Alex Roberts | Updated: 8/31/2018 10:05:20 PM

Below are the list of top 25 best restaurants in Mattituck,NY.

# Michelangelo Pizzeria

10095 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-4100

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Iron Skillet

730 Love Ln
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-1235

Dishes Served:

American, Italian

# Love Lane Kitchen

240 Love Ln
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-8989

Dishes Served:

American, Burger

# Yogurt Expressions

13175 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-7954

Dishes Served:

Desserts, Beverages

# A Mano

13550 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-4800

Dishes Served:

Italian, Seafood

# The Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

55 Middle Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-1947

Dishes Served:

Pizza

# Magic Fountain

9825 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-4908

Dishes Served:

Desserts

# Jan's Chinese Food

10095 Main Rd #16
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-2066

Dishes Served:

Chinese

# CJ's American Grill

10095 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-315-5311

Dishes Served:

American

# North Fork Market & Deli

11155 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-5570

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Ammirati's

135 Love Ln
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-7812

Dishes Served:

# The Village Cheese Shop

105 Love Ln
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-8556

Dishes Served:

Coffee and Tea, International, Sandwich

# Wendy's Deli

55 Middle Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-298-1500

Dishes Served:

Sandwich

# Pace's Dockside Restaurant

2255 Wickham Ave
Mattituck , NY 11952

Visit Website
Ph: 631-315-5252

Dishes Served:

American

# The Broken Down Valise

180 Pike St
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-9796

Dishes Served:

# Sideyard

10560 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-8076

Dishes Served:

# Antique Catering & Deli

10560 Main Rd
Mattituck , NY 11952

Ph: 631-298-8808

Dishes Served:

Sandwich